← All comparisons
Atelier vs ast-grep

What ast-grep says, vs. what it scored.

Tree-sitter AST pattern matcher for structural search-and-rewrite -- precise if you already know the exact shape of the code you want.

What ast-grep says about itself
“ast-grep can precisely search code based on AST, running through ten thousand files in sub seconds.”
Publishes no numbers ...never against another search tool ~10k stars
What it actually scored — same 14 repos, same 7,213 queries as every other tool
Tool MRR p95 p100
Atelier +semantic (BGE) 0.727 390ms 1057ms
Atelier lexical (default) 0.676 134ms 319ms
ast-grep 0.312 1255ms 8806ms

"Sub seconds through ten thousand files" is a fair speed claim for literal AST-pattern matching -- ast-grep even publishes a tool-comparison page, but it's feature checkboxes against Semgrep/GritQL/Comby, not a quantitative accuracy number. It needs an exact structural pattern, so on natural-language "where does X happen" queries it lands 0.312 MRR -- behind plain ripgrep.

The true story

Every tool in this comparison, ast-grep included, has been through the exact same 14 repositories and 7,213 query/gold pairs that score Atelier — no cherry-picked queries, no separate corpus. Full methodology, every raw number, and the other 9 tools →